Sorry, Dylan, but you're going to have to accept defeat on that one. The headlight bucket is crunched and skewed and will never be right again. Even the hole it fits into would be nearly impossible to get round again, rendering replacing the bucket a lost cause. Also, right above the bucket on Beetle fenders there are a series of crowns and reverse crowns, and they are all smashed flat on this one. It might be possible to repair but I could easily see it taking a week and a half of work to do.

Dan